M3 follow-up: SETUP.md rewritten for single-project approach

Q: Should I just create an iOS target in the current scarf project?
   Would that be easier?
A: Yes — single scarf.xcodeproj with two targets (scarf + scarf-ios)
   is objectively easier than a separate scarf-ios.xcodeproj.

The original conservative recommendation (separate xcodeproj) was
rooted in my not wanting to hand-edit pbxproj. But you're the one
clicking through Xcode's UI to create the target, not me — Xcode
handles multi-target multi-platform projects natively, with zero
risk to the existing Mac target.

Rewrote SETUP.md to describe the single-project flow:

  - `File → New → Target` inside the existing project (not a new
    project file).
  - Both targets share the same SPM package references — ScarfCore
    is already there for Mac, you just add it + ScarfIOS to the
    scarf-ios target via General → Frameworks.
  - One Xcode window, one scheme switcher, unified signing/team
    settings.

Also threaded in M3-specific smoke-test steps (connect to a real
host → see Dashboard load via Citadel SFTP snapshot) and added a
post-M3 troubleshooting entry for the `Cannot find 'Process' in
scope` error — it should never appear now that makeProcess is
`#if !os(iOS)`-guarded, but if it does it's a leaked Mac-only file
in the scarf-ios target membership.

Milestone status table in SETUP.md updated to reflect M3 shipped.

https://claude.ai/code/session_019yMRP6mwZWfzVrPTqevx2y

scarf/scarf-ios/SETUP.md

@@ -1,170 +1,195 @@
 # scarf-ios — Xcode target setup
 
-This folder contains the source tree for the iOS app (`scarf-ios`), but
+This folder contains the source tree for the iOS app (`scarf-ios`).
-**not** the Xcode project file. Creating the `.xcodeproj` is a one-time
+The Xcode target itself is added to the **existing `scarf.xcodeproj`**
-step you do in Xcode's UI — it's about 5 minutes, and doing it by hand
+as a second target alongside the Mac `scarf` target — **not** a
-produces a project file that's definitely correct for whichever Xcode
+separate `.xcodeproj`. One project, two targets.
-version you're running, rather than a hand-edited pbxproj that might
-drift from Xcode's expectations.
 
 Everything the app needs — SSH key generation, Keychain storage,
-onboarding state machine, Citadel-backed connection testing — already
+onboarding state machine, Citadel-backed SSH client, SQLite-backed
-lives in the shared SPM packages (`Packages/ScarfCore`,
+Dashboard — already lives in the shared SPM packages
-`Packages/ScarfIOS`) and is exercised by 88 passing unit tests on
+(`Packages/ScarfCore`, `Packages/ScarfIOS`) and is exercised by
-Linux CI. The Xcode target is mostly just a wrapper that assembles
+96 passing unit tests on Linux CI. The iOS target is mostly just a
-those packages behind a `@main` SwiftUI app.
+wrapper that assembles those packages behind a `@main` SwiftUI app.
 
-## One-time: create the Xcode target
+Creating the target is a one-time ~5-minute step in Xcode's UI.
 
-1. Open **Xcode** → **File → New → Project…**
+## One-time: add the iOS target to the existing project
-2. Choose **iOS → App**. Click Next.
+
-3. Fill in:
+1. Open `scarf/scarf.xcodeproj` in **Xcode**.
+2. Select the project in the Project Navigator.
+3. **File → New → Target…** (or use the `+` button at the bottom of
+   the targets list).
+4. Choose **iOS → App**. Click Next.
+5. Fill in:
    - **Product Name**: `scarf-ios`
-   - **Team**: `3Q6X2L86C4` (the same team the Mac app uses for notarization)
+   - **Team**: `3Q6X2L86C4` (the same team the Mac target uses)
    - **Organization Identifier**: `com.scarf`
+   - **Bundle Identifier** will be `com.scarf.scarf-ios`
    - **Interface**: **SwiftUI**
    - **Language**: **Swift**
-   - **Storage**: **None** (no Core Data, no CloudKit)
+   - **Storage**: **None**
    - **Include Tests**: unchecked (SPM covers them)
-4. On the save-location sheet, navigate to `<repo>/scarf/` (the same
+6. Click **Finish**. Xcode creates the target plus a default source
-   level as `scarf.xcodeproj`) and hit **Create**.
+   tree under `scarf/scarf-ios/` (a folder you'll immediately throw
-5. Xcode produces `<repo>/scarf/scarf-ios/scarf-ios.xcodeproj` and a
+   away, since our real source lives there already).
-   default source tree you'll immediately throw away.
+7. If Xcode asks about "Activate scheme": **yes**.
 
-## One-time: set project settings
+## One-time: target settings
 
-In the **scarf-ios** project (target of the same name):
+With the `scarf-ios` target selected in the project editor:
 
 1. **General → Minimum Deployments → iPhone**: `iOS 18.0`.
 2. **General → Supported Destinations**: keep **iPhone** only. Remove
    iPad + Mac Catalyst + Vision.
-3. **Info → Bundle Identifier**: `com.scarf.scarf-ios`.
+3. **Signing & Capabilities → Team**: `3Q6X2L86C4` (should have
-4. **Signing & Capabilities → Team**: `3Q6X2L86C4` (same as Mac).
+   auto-filled from step 5 above).
-5. **Build Settings → Swift Language Version**: `Swift 5` (matches
+4. **Build Settings → Swift Language Version**: `Swift 5` (matches
-   the Mac app and both SPM packages).
+   the Mac target + both SPM packages).
 
-## One-time: wire the SPM packages
+## One-time: link the SPM packages to the iOS target
 
-1. **File → Add Package Dependencies…**
+`ScarfCore` and `ScarfIOS` are already in the project's package
-2. **Add Local…** button in the lower-left of the dialog.
+references (the Mac target already uses ScarfCore). You only need to
-3. Select `<repo>/scarf/Packages/ScarfCore`. Click **Add Package**.
+add them to the NEW iOS target.
-4. Target to attach it to: **scarf-ios**. Click **Add Package**.
+
-5. Repeat steps 1–4 for `<repo>/scarf/Packages/ScarfIOS`.
+1. Select the project in the navigator → select the `scarf-ios`
-   - `ScarfIOS` already declares `Citadel` as a dependency — Xcode
+   target → **General → Frameworks, Libraries, and Embedded
-     will resolve it automatically when you add the local package.
+   Content**.
-   - On first resolution expect a ~30s wait while Citadel +
+2. Click the `+` button.
-     SwiftNIO-SSH fetch from GitHub.
+3. Select **ScarfCore** (library from ScarfCore local package). Add.
+4. Click `+` again. Select **ScarfIOS**. Add.
+5. Citadel is pulled in transitively by ScarfIOS — no need to add it
+   explicitly. On first build Xcode resolves it from GitHub
+   (~30s-1min).
 
 ## One-time: replace the default source tree
 
-1. In Xcode's Project Navigator, delete the auto-generated files
+1. In Xcode's Project Navigator, find the `scarf-ios` group Xcode
-   Xcode created for you:
+   created. Delete:
    - `scarf_iosApp.swift` (or `scarf-iosApp.swift`)
    - `ContentView.swift`
-   - **`Assets.xcassets`** — yes, delete this one too. We ship a
+   - **`Assets.xcassets`** — we ship our own pre-built one.
-     pre-built `Assets.xcassets/` with the app icon + accent
+2. In Finder, open `<repo>/scarf/scarf-ios/`. Drag these four folders
-     color inside `<repo>/scarf/scarf-ios/` that we'll add in the
+   onto the `scarf-ios` group in Xcode:
-     next step.
+   - `App/`
-2. In Finder, open `<repo>/scarf/scarf-ios/`. Drag **App/**,
+   - `Onboarding/`
-   **Onboarding/**, **Dashboard/**, and **`Assets.xcassets/`** onto
+   - `Dashboard/`
-   the `scarf-ios` target in Xcode's navigator.
+   - `Assets.xcassets/`
-   - In the import sheet: **Create groups**, **Add to target:
+3. In the import sheet:
-     scarf-ios**.
+   - **Destination**: Copy items if needed — **unchecked** (they're
-3. Build (`⌘B`). It should compile cleanly against Citadel 0.12.1
+     already in place).
-   — every API call in `CitadelSSHService` was cross-checked
+   - **Added folders**: **Create groups**.
-   against the 0.12.1 tag in April 2026. If you've bumped the pin
+   - **Add to targets**: **scarf-ios** only.
-   to 0.13+ and something fails here, the likeliest culprit is
+4. Build (`⌘B`). Should compile cleanly against Citadel 0.12.1 —
-   `SSHAuthenticationMethod.ed25519(username:privateKey:)` being
+   every API call in `CitadelSSHService` + `CitadelServerTransport`
-   renamed or refactored; check the current
+   was cross-checked against the 0.12.1 tag. If you've bumped the
-   `Sources/Citadel/SSHAuthenticationMethod.swift` in the new
+   pin to 0.13+ and something fails, check
-   release.
+   `Sources/Citadel/SSHAuthenticationMethod.swift` for the current
+   `.ed25519(username:privateKey:)` spelling.
 
 ## App icon + accent color
 
-The `Assets.xcassets/` inside `<repo>/scarf/scarf-ios/` ships with:
+Already in `Assets.xcassets/` so you don't configure anything:
 
 - **`AppIcon.appiconset/AppIcon-1024.png`** — the 1024×1024 Scarf
-  icon from the Mac app's icon set. iOS 14+ renders all smaller
+  icon copied from the Mac app's icon set. iOS 14+ renders all
-  sizes automatically from the single 1024 image.
+  smaller sizes automatically from the single 1024 image.
-- **`AccentColor.colorset`** — a custom Scarf teal (`RGB
+- **`AccentColor.colorset`** — custom Scarf teal (sRGB `0.227 /
-  0.227 / 0.525 / 0.722` in light mode; lighter `0.400 / 0.690
+  0.525 / 0.722` light mode; `0.400 / 0.690 / 0.902` dark). Edit
-  / 0.902` in dark mode). If you want a different accent, swap
+  `Contents.json` or Xcode's color picker to change.
-  the sRGB components in `Contents.json` or edit in Xcode's
-  color picker.
 
-## Info.plist additions for M2
+## Info.plist for TestFlight
 
-None required. Citadel uses SwiftNIO, which doesn't need the
+Under the scarf-ios target → **Info → Custom iOS Target Properties**:
-network-usage `Info.plist` key unless you hit local-network
-discovery — which onboarding doesn't.
 
-If you want to publish to TestFlight in M2, add these under
+- `LSRequiresIPhoneOS = YES` (usually defaulted)
-**Info → Custom iOS Target Properties**:
-
-- `LSRequiresIPhoneOS = YES` (defaults to YES, usually already set)
 - `UIApplicationSceneManifest → UIApplicationSupportsMultipleScenes = NO`
-  (single-window for iPhone)
+  (iPhone single-window)
-- `UILaunchScreen` — empty dictionary is fine.
+- `UILaunchScreen` — empty dictionary is fine
 
-## Smoke test the target
+Citadel uses SwiftNIO, not Apple's local-network discovery, so no
+network-usage-description key is needed.
 
-1. Pick an iPhone simulator (any iPhone running iOS 18+) and hit ⌘R.
+## Smoke test
-2. You should see the onboarding flow: **Remote host** form → **SSH
-   key** choice → **Generate** → **Show public key** → …
-3. On **Show public key**, the OpenSSH line is selectable and
-   copy-able. The text renders as `ssh-ed25519 AAAA… scarf-iphone-XXXX`.
-4. Tap **I've added this key**. Onboarding calls `CitadelSSHService`
-   to connect. With no real server, this will fail with
-   `.hostUnreachable` — that's expected. You should land on the
-   **Connection failed** screen with a "Retry" button.
-5. Real end-to-end test: use a host you actually own, copy the shown
-   public key into its `~/.ssh/authorized_keys`, tap Retry. You
-   should reach the **Connected** state and then the placeholder
-   **Dashboard** with a Disconnect button.
 
-## TestFlight (still M2 — optional)
+1. Switch the run destination to an iPhone simulator (any iPhone
+   running iOS 18+). Xcode's target switcher lets you toggle between
+   scarf (macOS) and scarf-ios.
+2. ⌘R. Expect the onboarding flow:
+   **Remote host** → **SSH key choice** → **Generate** → **Show
+   public key** → **I've added this** → **Test connection** → ...
+3. On **Show public key**, the OpenSSH line is selectable + copyable
+   (`ssh-ed25519 AAAA… scarf-iphone-XXXX`).
+4. Without a real SSH server, **Test connection** will fail with
+   `.hostUnreachable` — that's expected. Land on the **Connection
+   failed** screen with a **Retry** button.
+5. Real end-to-end: use a host you own. Copy the shown public key
+   into `~/.ssh/authorized_keys` on that host. Tap **Retry**. You
+   should reach **Connected** → **Dashboard**, which then does a
+   Citadel SFTP snapshot of `~/.hermes/state.db` and renders
+   session + token stats.
 
-1. **Product → Archive** (select a physical iPhone or "Any iOS
+## TestFlight upload
-   Device (arm64)" as the target).
-2. **Window → Organizer → Archives → Distribute App → App Store
-   Connect → Upload**. Uses your existing team signing setup.
-3. First upload will trigger App Store Connect to create the app
-   record if it doesn't exist. Give it `com.scarf.scarf-ios` and
-   the same team.
-4. After processing, invite testers from App Store Connect.
 
-## What's *not* in M2
+1. Scheme selector top-left → **scarf-ios**. Destination: **Any iOS
+   Device (arm64)** or a physical iPhone.
+2. **Product → Archive**.
+3. **Window → Organizer → Archives → Distribute App → App Store
+   Connect → Upload**.
+4. First upload creates the App Store Connect app record with
+   `com.scarf.scarf-ios`. Same team as the Mac app.
+5. Invite testers from App Store Connect.
 
-- Dashboard data (sessions, messages, stats) — **M3** adds a
+## What's in each milestone
-  Citadel-backed `ServerTransport` so `HermesDataService` and friends
+
-  work over SSH from iOS.
+- **M2** — Onboarding (SSH key + Keychain), Citadel-based
-- Chat — **M4** adds an `SSHExecACPChannel` (the iOS counterpart to
+  "Test Connection", Dashboard placeholder.
-  `ProcessACPChannel`) so `ACPClient` runs over a Citadel exec
+- **M3** — Real Dashboard via `CitadelServerTransport` +
-  session.
+  `HermesDataService` (you're running the M3 PR now).
-- Memory editing, Cron, Skills, Settings — **M5**.
+- **M4** — Chat over an iOS `SSHExecACPChannel`.
-- Polish, App Store submission — **M6**.
+- **M5** — Memory editing, Cron, Skills, Settings.
+- **M6** — Polish + App Store submission.
 
 ## Troubleshooting
 
-**Citadel fails to resolve.** Delete derived data (`~/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/scarf-ios-*`)
+**Citadel fails to resolve.** Delete DerivedData
-and `File → Packages → Reset Package Caches`, then rebuild.
+(`~/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/scarf-*`) and **File →
+Packages → Reset Package Caches**, then rebuild.
 
-**`SSHAuthenticationMethod` has no member `ed25519`.** Shouldn't
+**`Cannot find 'Process' in scope` when building scarf-ios.** Should
-happen against Citadel 0.12.1 (verified), but historically the
+not happen post-M3 — the `makeProcess` protocol method is now
-private-key variant names have changed between minor versions
+`#if !os(iOS)`-guarded. If you see this: grep the scarf-ios target's
-(0.7 → 0.9 → 0.12). See `CitadelSSHService.buildClientSettings(...)`
+source files for `Process()`, `process.isRunning`, or `terminationHandler`
-— there's one line to
+— something Mac-only leaked into the iOS target's membership.
-update. Keep the protocol conformance intact.
 
-**Keychain reads empty after relaunch.** Check that you haven't
+**`SSHAuthenticationMethod` has no member `ed25519`.** Shouldn't happen
-accidentally set `kSecAttrAccessible` to a value that requires
+against Citadel 0.12.1 (verified), but historically the private-key
-biometric unlock — M2 uses `AfterFirstUnlockThisDeviceOnly` which
+variant names have changed between minor versions (0.7 → 0.9 → 0.12).
-should always be readable.
+See `CitadelSSHService.buildClientSettings(...)` in ScarfIOS — one
+line to update. Keep the protocol conformance intact.
 
-**The shown public-key line doesn't match what OpenSSH generates
+**Dashboard shows "Couldn't read the Hermes database".** Expected if
-from the private key.** It won't — `scarf-ios` uses a compact
+the host's `~/.hermes/state.db` doesn't exist yet (fresh Hermes
-internal PEM shape for the private key (see `Ed25519KeyGenerator`
+install). Start a Hermes session on the host first, then pull-to-
-for the format). The **public** key is standard OpenSSH wire format
+refresh.
-and is interop-safe with `authorized_keys`. If you want to export
+
-the private key for use with `ssh`, that export flow is deferred
+**Dashboard spins forever on first connect.** Citadel connection
-to a future phase.
+hand-shake + SFTP open can take 5-10s on a cold network. If it's
+longer, check that the same SSH key works from a regular `ssh` client
+against the same host — sometimes the issue is an authorized_keys
+line with a trailing whitespace, or the host uses a restricted shell
+that blocks `sqlite3`.
+
+**Keychain reads empty after relaunch.** Check you haven't set
+`kSecAttrAccessible` to a biometric-required value. We use
+`AfterFirstUnlockThisDeviceOnly`, which is readable any time after
+the first post-boot unlock.
+
+**The public-key line doesn't match what `ssh-keygen` would produce
+from the same private key.** The **public** key is standard OpenSSH
+wire format (interop-safe with `authorized_keys`). The **private**
+key uses a compact Scarf-internal PEM (see
+`ScarfIOS/Ed25519KeyGenerator.swift`) — it's not directly exportable
+to `~/.ssh/id_ed25519`. A future phase adds an export flow that
+re-serializes to standard OpenSSH PEM.